The Complete Guide to Pool Resurfacing Options: Plaster, Pebble, or Quartz?

Premium Pools

July 10, 2025

Table of Content

Whether you’re planning to renovate an aging swimming pool or simply want to give your backyard a refreshed, luxurious look, choosing the right pool resurfacing option is one of the most important decisions you’ll make. The finish you select will not only impact the appearance of your pool but also determine its durability, comfort, maintenance needs, and overall cost.

In this complete guide, we’ll break down the three most popular pool resurfacing materials—plaster, pebble, and quartz—to help you choose the best finish for your pool.

Why Resurfacing Matters

Before diving into the material options, it’s important to understand why pool resurfacing is a necessary part of pool ownership. Over time, even the best-built pools develop surface issues such as:

Staining and discoloration
Cracks or pitting
Rough, abrasive textures
Leaks or water loss
Mold or algae buildup

These problems not only impact aesthetics but can also affect swimmer comfort, safety, and long-term structural integrity. Resurfacing corrects these issues while providing a brand-new finish that can last anywhere from 8 to 20+ years, depending on the material.

To make the most of your investment, it’s essential to select the right surface for your needs, climate, and budget.

Option 1: Traditional White Plaster

Plaster is the most widely used and cost-effective pool finish. Made from a mix of white cement, limestone, and water, plaster creates a smooth, clean-looking surface that gives pools a classic light blue color.

Pros:

Affordable: Ideal for homeowners on a budget
Smooth Texture: Comfortable for swimmers
Timeless Appearance: Clean, bright, and simple look
Easy to Install: Most contractors are well-versed in applying plaster

Cons:

Shorter Lifespan: Typically lasts 7–10 years
Prone to Staining: Can discolor if not maintained properly
More Maintenance: Requires close attention to water chemistry

Best For:

Homeowners seeking a classic, budget-friendly finish
Pools that are not heavily exposed to extreme weather or chemicals

Option 2: Quartz Finish

Quartz pool finishes are an upgraded version of plaster, with crushed quartz particles added to the mix. This makes the surface more durable, stain-resistant, and attractive. Quartz is available in a wide range of colors, allowing you to customize the look of your pool more than with plaster alone.

Pros:

Stronger and More Durable: Lasts 10–15 years
More Color Choices: Allows for creative designs and deeper water colors
Stain-Resistant: Less prone to discoloration
Luxurious Look: Gives the pool a shimmering, high-end appearance

Cons:

Higher Cost Than Plaster: Generally 25–40% more expensive
Rougher Feel Than Plaster: Though still comfortable

Best For:

Homeowners who want a balance of beauty, longevity, and value
Pools in sunny, high-use areas like South Florida where durability matters

Looking to upgrade to a quartz finish? You can explore your options with our trusted pool resurfacing services.

Option 3: Pebble Finish

Pebble finishes are considered the top tier in terms of both durability and aesthetics. These surfaces are created using small, polished river pebbles blended into the cement. The result is a natural, textured surface that mimics the look of a lagoon or high-end resort pool.

Pros:

Exceptionally Durable: Can last 15–25 years or longer
Unique Appearance: Offers a natural, organic look
Resistant to Stains, Chemicals, and Harsh Elements
Low Maintenance: Easy to clean and maintain

Cons:

Most Expensive Option: Up to 2x the cost of plaster
Textured Feel: May be rougher than plaster or quartz (though many find it pleasant)

Best For:

Homeowners seeking luxury and long-term performance
Outdoor pools that get a lot of sun, salt, or chlorinated water exposure
People who want a natural, upscale finish for their backyard retreat

Which Finish Is Right for You?

When choosing between plaster, quartz, and pebble, ask yourself the following:

How long do you want the finish to last?
- Plaster is economical but short-lived.
- Quartz and pebble offer longer durability.
What is your budget?
- Plaster is the most budget-friendly.
- Quartz and pebble are more expensive but add value and require less maintenance.
How much maintenance are you comfortable with?
- Plaster requires more upkeep.
- Pebble and quartz are more forgiving.
What style are you going for?
- Plaster: Clean and simple.
- Quartz: Colorful and sparkling.
- Pebble: Natural and upscale.

What About Installation?

No matter what finish you choose, the quality of the installation is just as important as the material itself. A poorly applied surface—no matter how durable—will fail sooner and may not perform as intended.

Working with professional, experienced contractors is key. When selecting a company for pool resurfacing services, make sure they:

Specialize in resurfacing, not just general pool maintenance
Are licensed, insured, and have strong references
Use certified materials and follow best application practices

Final Thoughts

Each pool resurfacing material offers its own blend of beauty, longevity, and cost. Whether you prefer the affordability of plaster, the enhanced strength and color of quartz, or the luxury appeal of a pebble finish, your choice will influence how you enjoy your pool for years to come.

Take the time to explore all options, weigh their pros and cons, and discuss them with trusted resurfacing professionals who understand your goals and local climate conditions.

When you’re ready to make the upgrade, reach out to a reliable pool renovation team with experience in plaster, pebble, and quartz finishes — and enjoy a backyard oasis that looks and feels brand new.

Meta Title: Pool Resurfacing Options: Plaster vs. Pebble vs. Quartz | Complete Guide 2025
Meta Description: Explore the pros and cons of plaster, pebble, and quartz pool finishes. Learn which resurfacing option is best for your pool, budget, and long-term maintenance goals.
Meta Tags: pool resurfacing services